Sin, Evil and Forgiveness


Many older liturgies have confessions like this:

..........................we have sinned against You.............in thought word and deed
                                    in the evil we have done and in the good we have not done


Failing to do "good" is certainly a sin, but are "doing evil" and "sinning" the same thing ? I suggest not. This sort of wording comes about because good and evil are conventional opposites.

Consider the Lord's prayer:


................forgive us our sins (as we forgive....... and lead us not into temptation) BUT deliver us from evil

It seems there is a difference between Sin and Evil. Sin can be forgiven but Evil requires Deliverance. This is not just semantics it has important consequences for daily life and our attitude to crime in particular.

Consider also Ephesians 6 Vs 11-12 (Click for a modern version)

11  Put on the whole armour of God, that ye may be able to stand against the wiles of the devil.
12  For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers
     of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.


We might be tempted (!) to interpret high places as referring to our worthy Government, but no, it refers to the spiritual dimension. There is no doubt that Jesus believed in Evil Spirits and cast them out just as often as He forgave sins. To the best of my memory He never did both on the same person. 

I am content to take evil spirits literally, if you dear reader cannot, then at least accept them as a parable  for what God has allowed to exist in our world alongside but different from sin. Equally: do not imagine devils as cute little fellows in red flannel with horns and a pointy tail, we are dealing with the depths of human experience. I do not claim to have a clear definition to differentiate evil from sin and I do not want to dwell in particular examples when tabloid newspapers scream EVIL in their headlines, but let me try a simple hypothetical example. Holding a knife up to someone and demanding money is sin and serious sin, but holding a knife to a baby’s throat to demand money from its mother is evil. What really differentiates them is not the extent or depth of the wickedness, but whether we would feel it reasonable to ask the victim, under the right conditions, to consider forgiving the perpetrator. No-one should ask the parent of a murdered child to forgive the murderer or even mention the idea. We might, however, hope that the parent can eventually move on from hatred, simply because carrying hatred is corrosive and destructive. Once evil has struck, everyone concerned is in danger of being tainted by it, not least the journalists who report and dwell on it. I suggest that hatred is a symptom of the presence of evil.

I could go on about famous dictators and perpetrators of terrible acts of terrorism, but there is a danger that these words could then become tainted by evil. Instead I prefer to suggest that, if there is a particular one on your mind, or when you see the next on the television, that you stop and consider whether such a thing could ever be forgivable. If you think not then label it as Evil. Take no concern whatever about forgiveness, rather pray that we are all delivered from evil. Among other things that means being delivered from the hatred we might feel.

What then of Jesus and the Cross? I remind you that Jesus did not say of Judas that he would be forgiven, rather that it would have been better for him if he had never been born. (Mark 14 v12). Forgiveness of all our sins is possible through the Cross, but if we get sucked into Evil we are doomed.


Return to Papers Index